ALP vs Traditional Tutoring: What is the difference?

Anne-Marie

When it comes to helping our children succeed academically, every parent wants to make the best decision. In this blog, we’ll explore the differences between ALP and traditional tutoring, why children might benefit from ALP, and how Education, Health and Care Plans (EHCPs) fit into the picture.

What Is ALP?

Alternative Learning Provision (ALP) refers to educational support provided to children who, for various reasons, may not thrive in mainstream schooling environments. This might mean they are still ‘on roll’ at school, but are not currently attending, or this may be alongside attending school some of the time. ALP is often a beneficial option for students with special educational needs (SEN), those with emotional or behavioural challenges, or children who are unable to attend traditional school due to illness or EBSA (Emotionally Based School Avoidance).

ALP can take many forms, including one-on-one tutoring, small group lessons, or online learning. It may focus on academic subjects and passing exams or on developing life skills and building confidence, depending on the child’s needs. Often, ALP is provided in a more flexible and informal setting than traditional schooling, which can make it more suitable for children who struggle in a mainstream school environment.

Why Might Children Need ALP?

Children require ALP for a variety of reasons, and identifying the root cause is essential to determining the most appropriate form of support. Some reasons children might benefit from ALP include:

  1. Special Educational Needs and Disabilities (SEND): Children with SEND may find mainstream schools too challenging if their specific needs aren’t met. Traditional schooling can sometimes struggle to offer the personalised support necessary to help them thrive. ALP can be tailored to provide the right level of challenge and support, making learning accessible and enjoyable for these students.
  2. Emotional or Behavioural Difficulties: For children with conditions such as ADHD, autism, or those experiencing anxiety and depression, a traditional classroom can feel overwhelming. The structured environment, social pressures, and demands of mainstream schooling can contribute to stress, which in turn affects learning. ALP offers a more relaxed environment that prioritises the child’s mental well-being alongside their education.
  3. Chronic Illness or Physical Disabilities: Some children cannot attend school regularly due to ongoing medical conditions or physical disabilities. ALP can offer a more flexible learning schedule, allowing students to continue their education at home or in a specialised environment. 
  4. Risk of Exclusion from School: Unfortunately, there are cases where children and young people are at risk of, or have been excluded from school. In these cases, ALP can serve as a bridge, helping the child to reintegrate into mainstream education, or offering a longer-term solution where mainstream schooling may not be appropriate.

What Does ALP Look Like?

The beauty of ALP is its adaptability. It’s not a one-size-fits-all approach but instead is moulded around the individual needs of the child. 

  1. One-on-One Tutoring: Some children benefit from one-on-one attention, especially those with SEN. Personalised tutoring allows for learning at a pace that suits the child and can be tailored to their interests and strengths.
  2. Small Group Learning: For children who benefit from a more social learning environment but still need additional support, small group lessons can be a good option. This setting provides interaction with peers without the overwhelming size of a typical classroom.
  3. Online Learning Platforms: For children unable to attend school physically, online learning can offer a structured education from home. Online tutoring or virtual classrooms provide flexibility and allow children to progress at their own pace.
  4. Holistic Learning Approaches: Some ALP settings focus not just on academic achievement, but also on developing social, emotional, and practical life skills. These settings may combine traditional learning with mentoring services, helping children to build resilience and self-esteem alongside their studies.

Traditional Tutoring: The Tried-and-Tested Method

Traditional tutoring is a more familiar concept to most parents. Whether through private tutors or after-school clubs, this method typically involves supplementary teaching in core subjects like Maths, English, and Science. Traditional tutoring works well for children who are looking to improve their performance or to prepare for exams, or who need a boost in a particular subject.

For children who are mostly coping or succeeding in mainstream education but need a little extra support, traditional tutoring can be a great option. It provides targeted help in areas where they may be struggling, without taking them out of the school environment.

EHCPs and ALP

In the UK, children with special educational needs may be entitled to an Education, Health and Care Plan (EHCP). An EHCP is a legal document that outlines the educational, health, and social care support a child with SEND. These plans are vital in ensuring that children with SEND receive the help they need to access education.

For some children, ALP will be part of their EHCP. For example, a child with severe autism may be placed in a specialised educational setting that forms part of their ALP. Alternatively, a child with anxiety might have an EHCP that specifies part-time attendance at mainstream school, supplemented by ALP such as one-on-one tutoring or therapy sessions.

Homeschooling: An Alternative Approach

Homeschooling is another option to consider when thinking about your child’s education. In the UK, parents have the legal right to educate their children at home if they wish, and for some families, this provides the flexibility and personalised attention that their child needs. Homeschooling can also be combined with ALP to provide a more structured curriculum, with professional tutors helping to cover areas that parents might find difficult to teach themselves.

However, homeschooling isn’t always the right option for every family. It requires a significant time commitment from parents and may not provide the same level of social interaction that children would get in a traditional school or ALP setting.

My child has an EHCP. Does this mean they need ALP instead of traditional tutoring?

The short answer is – no! Deciding between ALP, traditional tutoring, and homeschooling depends on your child’s specific needs, abilities, and circumstances. The aim of an EHCP is to help children with SEND to access education, so if they are attending school full time and are happy with how things are going, but need an extra boost, traditional tuition is perfect for them. However, if they struggle in a mainstream school setting due to SEN, emotional difficulties, or health concerns, and their attendance is at risk of dropping, ALP could provide the personalised support they need. This is a discussion that would need to be had with your child’s school, to go over exactly how the two could work side by side. Alternatively, it might be the school or local authority that comes to you and recommends ALP – every situation is different, and there is no “one size fits all” approach.

For parents considering homeschooling, it’s important to think about whether you have the time and resources to support your child’s education fully, or whether you might benefit from combining homeschooling with ALP or traditional tutoring.

Ultimately, the best choice is the one that allows your child to feel supported, engaged, and excited about learning. Every child is different, and what works for one may not work for another. By considering all the options and seeking advice from professionals, you can make an informed decision that sets your child on the path to success.

Research and Insights from the UK

Research has shown that children who struggle in mainstream education often benefit from ALP. According to a study by the Department for Education, pupils in ALP settings showed marked improvements in their attendance and behaviour. 

Homeschooling has also grown in popularity in the UK, particularly since the COVID-19 pandemic, with an estimated 115% increase in the number of families choosing to homeschool between 2020 and 2021, according to the BBC. This surge suggests that more parents are exploring alternatives to mainstream schooling as they seek the best educational fit for their children.

According to a 2021 report by the National Autistic Society, many children with autism do not receive adequate support in mainstream education. The report highlighted that 74% of parents felt their child’s school placement did not meet their needs, and nearly half of autistic students felt their special educational needs were unmet​ (National Autistic Society) This showcases the significant gap in provision for children with SEND, often making ALP a more suitable choice for such students.

According to a recent government report on SEND and Alternative Provision, the UK government has committed to improving the quality and availability of alternative educational settings. This includes introducing new national standards and improving access to tailored educational support​ (GOV.UK) (House of Commons Library).

Enhancing futures through tutoring and mentoring

Greenhouse Learning offers a personalised tutoring and mentoring service, tailored to the needs of the individual. Get in touch with us to discuss how we can help you support your child to achieve their full potential.